What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Honolulu, Hawaii for the first time?

Check the fishing reports. For some reason, marlin were showing up off of Oahu. Normally people fish for marlin off of the Big Island (Kona side). The captain and deck hand were as thrilled as we were! They were masterful at spotting opportunities to hook into these blue marlin and striped marlin.

In the pictures online it displayed outlets, speakers, water hose but none of that worked The speakers didn’t work so no music I would have brought my blue tooth speaker to get music going and set the vibe The outlets didn’t work so I couldn’t keep my phone charged to take pictures of the day which also sucked as it showed outlets and I brought my charger but couldn’t use it No fresh water tank to hose off the salt water that was on us and kids Overall the boat didn’t come equipped with what it shows and kind of ruined the day as a little communication stating these things didn’t work at least I can come prepared with a portable charger and portable speaker and bring more water to wash off. When you spend that much money nearly 2k on a day private charter you would think this would come standard. I was disappointed with the day for sure and my kids were also a little sad.

I recommend to be sure for anyone who wants to experience fishing safely, with kindness and good equipment. I think his assistant name was Tito (sorry if I got it wrong) but what a nice young man he was! He even cooked the caught fish while we were on boat and everyone shared. I thought it was great! And most certainly good value for money spent! I have paid way more to fish while on my worldly travels and even grand expensive trips may produce not catching any. Part of the deal with fishing. I’m ok with trying and enjoying anyway! I only wish I had more time there and I would have had the captain take me on one of his deep sea fishing trips!!

I had to rate bad because we did not catch anything some others may have had a better experience. Not good for small children they would be bored small boat nothing to do and make sure you bring food and water.

The Captain and crew will guide first timers through the process to keep everyone safe and maximize the opportunity to bring the fish. I’ve been on a few charters in Honolulu, all outstanding experiences.

This was my first charter trip, and if I had it to do over again, I would ask more questions about the type of fishing that was going to be done. I prefer a more active role when fishing, and in this case, the guides pretty much do it all. That’s understandable, since the gear is considerably heavier and more elaborate than what I’ve experienced before! Not my cup of tea, but if you’re after big fish, this is the boat and crew!

This trip was exactly what I expected for the price. Serious fisherman will want to choose a pricier option. Great trip for families with young kids! Boat was clean and comfortable and the crew was patient and kind!

Fishing is hard to review, because you can't make a fish bite the hook. They strike when they want too! We went for 6 hours pretty hard and didn't catch anything big, so that was disappointing. I'm not sure when's the best time to fish Hawaii, but we didn't have much luck the 3rd week of June.

Do research on type of fishing/charters (trolling, jigging etc) Wear sunblock, hat, bring anti nausea meds if you need it. Don’t have high expectations don’t expect to catch fish. Have fun make memories,

Note that you are going for a chance at catching some large sport fish. But it’s a chance - not a guarantee. It’s a big ocean and there are lots of variables that constantly change so it’s very possible you won’t catch anything. But you may be lucky and land an incredible once in a lifetime catch!

Again, it is called fishing, not catching. These Captains and crews know the Hawaiian waters and how to catch these local fish, and will do their very best to put you on those fish. Remember, you aren't guaranteed to catch anything, amd remember, they are professionals at their jobs and doing their very best, so give them some slack if luck is bad.

Please always know that your captain and crew want to catch fish as badly as you. Sometimes they bite, sometimes they don't. If you catch fish, fantastic! If you dont, blame it on the fish. Those dudes and ladies know what they're doing and do everything possible to put you on fish. I've fished all over the world and it's about the experience. That's why we call it fishing and not catching!

Be prepared and know the fishing seasons here! Looks like it is all year round! Also be prepared for a fight of your life. Listen to your crew they know what they are doing and can help you be successful !

Obviously no guarantees with fishing but I’ve been very happy with my hawaii fishing experiences and even if you don’t catch anything it’s gorgeous seeing the island from the water, especially at sunrise.

You are on an island. When you go out a few miles you are in the middle of the ocean. The oceans swells get a bit large and at a few points we couldn’t see the island hotels. The crew are professionals and do this for a living this is very normal to them. Please treat them with the respect they deserve. You are on their boat, using their gear. It doesn’t matter if you have 100$ in fishing equipment or 30,000$. At the end of the day you can’t make the fish bite. Was well worth the trip for us and we didn’t bring a fish home.

Bring sunblock! We did not and we definitely felt it the next day. Take pictures! It’s an experience you’ll want to look back on. And be patient! It’s still fishing. You never know when the big one is going to hit.

This was our first time fishing hawaii we had deep sea fished in tofino BC and Cancun this ocean is easily rougher make sure to take something for sea sickness before going. Would still do it again though

This was our first time fishing in Hawaii, so not sure seasonally how fishing changes. Our trip started out pretty slow but glad we booked the full day. All our fish came in the afternoon. Caught multiple Mahi-mahi.

Remember it is called 'fishing' and not 'catching'. No one can control the weather, or make the fish bite. I have fished for over 50 years, so perhaps I have a bit more realistic approach, and expectations. You won't catch fish everytime you go out. When you can, and if you have the time and money, book a full day trip. It increases your chances of having a great day. Half-day charters are hard as it limits the time you have, and you may not catch the tides right.

Follow the crews instructions to keep your bait close to the bottom while not getting snagged and pretty soon you should be catching and not just fishing. Everyone in our party of 3 caught fish and only one was an experienced fisher.

Know any fishing anywhere is subjected to luck. You need to plan on having a good time and be pleasantly surprised if you get a catch. You never know if you get one or not anywhere so take that into consideration.

Reeling in a marlin is a “bucket list” experience. If you’re looking to take home fish you should look for a boat that is targeting smaller fish. If you want to take your chances to catch the fish of a lifetime and look for Marlin then I highly recommend five star fishing.

Do it! It’s fishing. Not catching! But if you’re somewhat of a fisherman or outdoors person, you’d understand. Sometimes the fish has the better of you and sometimes you have the better of them. The important thing is to pay attention to the crew to see how they are changing up rigs and tactics to put you on fish!

Make sure the captain and crew are knowledgeable about what you are catching. There are a lot of endangered species or illegal to catch fish in hawaii so if not could get in some big trouble real fast

This is definitely a first time, small catch, family fun type of outing. Boat was great for a party of 4, unsure how it would be for more people. Please note, taking seasick meds with you is probably a good idea, even if you think you won't need them.

To wear plenty of sunscreen and take your motion sickness medication. I would also book half a day or longer for the best opportunity to catch Marlin.

Find a highly rated boat/service. A private experience on a large vessel is my recommendation! Trust the captain, he does this for a living.

Do your research. Read the comments. If you want to catch a certain species, let them know before the trip, not the day of....

Fish haven’t been biting too often compared to other times of the year I have been here

Don’t take my word for it but go with Maggie Joe and have your own experience !