Fished with Captain Noah for a 4 hour shared charter.  Despite captain Noah’s young age (21).  He was outstanding!  Friendly, courteous, experienced.  We fished two areas, one wreck and one rock pile.  Successful and enjoyable experience!  We hooked in to several sharks that gave us an experience, along with several groupers that unfortunately were not in season.  The only suggestion that I can provide is for the owner of Coolcast charters to improve his response to phone calls/emails.  Several messages were sent and two voicemails were left on cell phone provided with no return.  Captain Noah will definitively be booked again and hopefully the next time will be for a full day charter instead of a 4 hour one.

Absolutely recommend Joey and Coolcast Charter! My husband and I did a fishing trip last time we were in Key West but this blew it out of the water! Great captain and a very hands on trip, actually being able to bait your own hook on your own pole - He knew when and where to move the boat when we weren’t catching anything right away, very friendly and informative. 11/10 recommend and will definitely be coming back on our next trip! Thanks for the best experience!

We had an excellent time with John. He is plain spoken and knowledgeable about everything from what your fishing to the birds you see while you fish. We had a slow start (no fault of his). Plenty of bites but we couldn’t deliver due to our inexperience.  After he coached us ( much more than he probably wanted to) we finally started landing the fish. It was an amazing time from start to finish. Captain John knows his business and explains what he is doing and why. He also allows you to learn the process and take part. He even told us half way through the day we could leave and catch a ton of smaller fish, but since I had asked him to stick it out and land nice sized fish he stayed. He was an amazing guide. I can’t recommend him highly enough. Thank you so much John. You made our trip!!!

Captain Sam worked his tail off keeping up with 5 anglers!  He warned us the wind would kick up the seas and there would be 8 miles of 4-6 footers.  He assured us if conditions were not favorable, we would stay closer and fish shallower water.

Capt. Sam put us on the fish!  He changed positions several times to keep us in good fishing.  We ended up with a great catch.  We had our catch of the day processed and were on our way to a recommended restaurant shortly after docking. 

My family of 5 adults had an awesome adventure!  The best part, my daughter took the species pot from her older brother.  No small feat in and of itself!!!

Capt John had us on yellowtail snapper almost as soon as he anchored the boat. We moved a few times during the day and caught fish everywhere. Capt John had a clean and roomy boat. His knowledge of the area’s history was a plus. We will definitely fish with him again